The AI-Driven Brand Reputation Crisis: Your Survival Guide

Imagine a potential customer asks an AI platform for the best solution in your industry. Instead of recommending you, it cites a Reddit comment with inaccurate information about your brand from three years ago. 

This isn’t a future problem — it’s happening right now, and it could be costing you customers. 

AI misinformation has caused a firestorm among established businesses. One simple mistake by large language models (LLMs) can be the reason you lose a lead or, worse, damage your brand reputation. 

In this guide, we not only unpack the AI-driven brand reputation crisis, but we also explore how to protect your brand reputation in AI search. 

What’s driving the brand reputation crisis?

AI misinformation is a major driver of recent brand reputation issues. AI search engines or LLMs like ChatGPT and Gemini build their understanding of your brand on the information they find online. Sometimes that information comes from Reddit threads, online forum discussions, and inaccurate or outdated content from reputable sites. 

A recent AI search study found that Reddit outranks corporate sites across all industries in AI search engine results. Here’s a quick look at the sources ChatGPT cites most: 

And here’s the percentage share of websites that Perplexity cites most: 

You’ll even find that Google trusts Reddit a great deal and trains its AI models on posts from the online discussion forum. Now, many of their searches include Reddit threads in the search engine results pages (SERPs). 

AI misinformation vs. AI hallucinations in LLMs

Before you can protect yourself from the AI-driven brand reputation crisis, you need to understand what AI issue you’re protecting yourself from. 

A more widely known LLM issue is AI hallucinations. AI hallucinations are factually inaccurate answers that the LLM creates when it lacks knowledge but still tries to answer. 

AI misinformation is a more accurate term for the issue you’re probably facing. AI-generated misinformation is false information caused by errors. It’s often influenced by outdated facts, biases, or leading prompts. 

Here is a table that will help you establish the issue you’re facing. 

If AI platforms are spreading biases or outdated facts about your brand, it’s probably AI brand misinformation. 

If AI answers are way off about your brand information and details, it’s likely that it’s a hallucination. Hallucinations mean that the LLM doesn’t know enough about your brand. In that case, you’ll need to enhance your AI visibility. 

Here’s the good news. You can control the way AI perceives your brand

Well, some of it. Here’s a closer look at the narratives you can control and the ones you can’t. 

Sure, it’s true that companies cannot always control these public narratives. But what if I told you there was a way to control these public narratives and reduce the damage AI does to your brand reputation? 

Before we get into those details, let’s first uncover your brand’s exposure to AI misinformation. 

How to audit your brand’s misinformation exposure

Want to know what LLMs are saying about your brand? You can evaluate and start to manage brand perception by following these steps. 

1. Create an automated or manual review process

Establish whether you plan to use an automated tool to review what LLMs say about your brand or manually feed LLMs prompts about your brand. Tools like OmniSEO™ can help you identify which AI search engines talk about your brand the most. 

Start by prompting those AI search engines with queries related to your brand, products, or services. Make sure your prompts include real-world examples of misinformation about your brand and biased narratives. 

2. Monitor responses for AI misinformation

Analyze LLM answers for biased opinions, inaccuracies, unverified claims, and harmful content about your brand. 

OmniSEO™ will help you identify which sources the engine cited most to generate those answers. This will tell you where most of these biases come from, whether online forums, reviews, or media. 

3. Establish the LLM’s interpretation of your brand

Now, you can start looking for patterns in LLM answers. Ask yourself: 

• Are there specific types of topics or prompts that consistently trigger negative or misleading responses? 
• Is the LLM showing bias or prejudices when discussing topics related to your brand? 
• How does the LLM rate the credibility of sources discussing your brand? 
• Is the LLM generating harmful URLs or dangerous information in relation to your brand? 
• Are there any noticeable knowledge gaps in which the LLM lacks knowledge or has inaccurate information about your brand? 

The patterns you find here will be crucial to informing a refined AI reputation strategy. 

Prevent AI misinformation and win back your reputation with these 7 steps

Now that you know what AI thinks about your brand, you can take the necessary steps to reduce the damage to your brand reputation based on your particular audit findings. Here’s how to protect your brand reputation in the age of AI. 

1. Flag AI misinformation

This is a simple one, but still very worth mentioning. As soon as you catch an inaccurate answer from LLMs, flag it and correct it with more accurate information. This will help you train them to avoid providing similar misinformation related to your brand. 

2. Update high-impact content

If the LLM you tested had knowledge gaps or provided inaccurate information, it’s possible that your website’s old and new content might contradict each other, creating inconsistencies across your site. 

Take time to fix and clarify inconsistencies in your brand story by updating your about page, service pages, and homepage. 

Otherwise, when creating new content, structure your articles with step-by-step guides, FAQ sections, bullet points, and tables. Doing so will enhance your content’s clarity and AI readability. 

If LLMs are citing more online forums than your official website, write more thought leadership content that addresses topics that your competitors are missing. Doing this and adding credentials to author bios will help you reinforce your brand’s authority, causing LLMs to cite your content more. 

3. Write more “best of” content

When people use AI search engines like ChatGPT to find the best company suited to their specific issue and needs, AI likes to cite “best of” blog posts for their answer. This offers a great opportunity for you to solidify brand product associations. 

For example, if your company offers a special needs homeschool curriculum, you could write an article titled “10 best homeschool curricula for special needs” and list your curriculum as the first. 

This specifies who your curriculum is for and positions your brand as the best in the industry. If your article ranks well, there’s a higher chance that ChatGPT will recommend your product to parents with children who have special needs. 

Here’s an example of a homeschool curriculum provider that positions their product as number one. 

4. Respond to communities in commonly cited websites

Is AI consistently citing Reddit, Quora, review sites, and other online forums? This is your opportunity to build a profile on the platform if you haven’t already and start engaging with the community. 

When Reddit users start threads to ask questions about your brand, respond to them yourself and offer valuable and authentic answers. 

Here are a few steps you can follow to do this right, especially if it’s on Reddit: 

Create a forum-appropriate profile

On Reddit, you want to create a plain profile that doesn’t include a business name or a link to your website and socials. It may sound strange, but you’ll gain more credibility if you avoid promoting your business and focus on offering valuable advice. 

Watch what people are saying

Spend some time reading people’s comments about your brand to get a feel for their issues and how you can help. 

Read forum guidelines

Before interacting with anyone, familiarize yourself with forum guidelines to avoid getting flagged for self-promotional content. 

Join the conversation

Whether it’s a subreddit or a forum discussion about your brand or industry, get involved in the discussions most likely to be cited by AI. Use some of these tips: 

• Answer direct “how to” questions related to your industry to build authority. 
• Fill in informational gaps in existing discussions. 
• Respond to negative and positive reviews. Thank them for the feedback and acknowledge your improvement areas to build trust. 

These small actions will reframe the way AI perceives your brand and improve the answers it gives to your target audience. 

5. Create posts on commonly cited forums

Aside from responding to existing comments, you also want to build a reputation based on your own posts within commonly cited forums. 

You can get ideas for forum posts from your top-performing comments or frequently asked questions related to your industry or brand within the forum. Your goal should be to provide helpful insights that allow users to solve an issue. 

You can also build credibility by sharing a case study about something you or a customer experienced. These often outline a problem, the steps you took to solve it, and the outcome. Here’s an example of a case study on Reddit that got a lot of attention: 

6. Build relationships with influencers and industry voices

Are AI search engines citing influencer channels and publications that post inaccurate information about your brand? 

In that case, you’ll want to build relationships with these industry voices. Reach out to them to clarify any misunderstandings they may have had about your brand and ask them to correct those content pieces. 

You can also partner with other industry publications and influencers and ask them to write more positive and accurate content about your brand. This will lead to more valuable brand mentions that AI can cite for users. 

7. Encourage happy customers to leave reviews

If AI is providing negative responses about your brand due to hostile subreddits and negative reviews on review sites, start encouraging your happy customers to leave a review. Another simple one, but it’s a great way to gain control over public narratives. 

Here are a few ways to effectively persuade customers or clients to leave a review: 

• Encourage them to use a QR code to leave a review while you complete the sale 
• Simplify or minimize the steps within the review process 
• Send direct links to the review page right after a positive experience 
• Offer discounts or exclusive offers upon leaving a review 
• Personalize your request for a review with their name and details about their experience 

Encourage them to leave detailed and honest reviews. AI likes to cite more detailed reviews when they relate directly to a user’s query. 

For example, let’s say a ChatGPT user prompts the search to provide examples of people who successfully won a court case similar to theirs. ChatGPT might then cite a review from someone who reached out to a specific law firm that helped them win the same type of court case that the user is currently experiencing. 

From AI crisis to AI confidence

Protecting your brand in the age of AI isn’t about fighting misinformation — it’s about leading the conversation. By following these tips and tricks, you can gain more control over public and brand narratives to win back your reputation. 

If you need an extra hand in creating website content that prevents AI misinformation, our experts at WebFX can take the reins. We’ll form a content marketing strategy that helps you enhance your brand reputation and drive revenue for your business. 

Browse our content marketing services or see how our AI brand visibility audit services can help you today.